An overwhelming grassroots vote against the police participation in Pride Toronto a couple years ago has now evolved into a near split vote.
Grassroots Pride Toronto members participated in a community vote tonight, both online and in person at a special meeting at Ryerson, and the result was 163 to 161 against police in uniform returning to Toronto Pride anytime soon. There were claims that a last minute influx of members might tip the balance in favour of the cops. But that didn't make the difference as supporters of the police ban still won the day.
If this community is this divided on the issue, it's clear that the status quo keeping the police out needs to remain for now. There's no grassroots push to bring the cops back.
I've struggled to decide how I feel about this issue. On the one hand, I see a ban as hopelessly divisive and somewhat counter-productive. On the other hand, letting police in would send a terrible message that we don't care that much about the near failure by the police as an organization to atone for their immense failures and injustices against the LGBTQ community (and other communities).
We do care deeply. Those opposed to the police returning to a community festival that originated as a political protest against oppression (still perpetuated on a regular basis by the police and their allies) have made impassioned arguments that I find impossible to refute.
So this vote will stand for the foreseeable future. Let's continue to debate and engage in our local community. I wrote late last year that Pride Toronto seemed a mess as an organization. Perhaps this grassroots vote will again revive its progressive legacy.
Let's get on with it.
The personal blog of @mattfguerin, loving husband, supervisor, writer, filmmaker, political junkie, union supporter based in Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Tuesday, January 22, 2019
Saturday, January 12, 2019
Ontario, and indeed all decent public school systems, have an obligation to challenge homophobia with an inclusive curriculum
The ongoing legal fight in Ontario over Doug Ford's decision to placate a small group of social conservative extremists hellbent on denying a safe environment for LGBTQ kids in our public schools grabbed our attention this week.
I'm proud of the parents, activists and groups who are leading this legal charge to return the modernized curriculum to our classrooms.
This great article by Martin Regg Cohn sums up the situation nicely, putting it in full context.
It's not enough for these conservative folks fighting the modern curriculum that they have always had the ability to remove their kids from sex education public school lessons (even though in my mind their kids most certainly need to learn them considering the backwards homes they are growing up in.) I can only think of the lasting damage caused to any unfortunate, lonely LGBTQ kids living in those homes by their parents' actions.
Yes it is important to protect kids from abuse, both in their homes and their schools. I firmly support the ability of greater society to create inclusive and healthy public school environments for all of us.
When I was a kid growing up, I was luckily in a family not too conservative. My family was fairly typical for the time period of the 1980s and 1990s. Since I came out of the closet to them all, our family situation has been pretty great, glad to say.
But high school was an awful experience, trying to survive amid the hotbed of homophobia that was mainstream back then. Social isolation was the rule of the day. Suicide was contemplated on occasion, but somehow I made it through without ever trying. Perhaps the faint hope of some kind of future as a gay adult kept me alive. Yet there was, of course, barely any mention of LGBT lives in my classrooms. Homosexuality came up on occasion. Most students were hostile to gay folk. Teachers, on the other hand, never indoctrinated or perpetuated ignorance or discrimination, even in my Catholic school environment.
Yet overall, the environment was hostile with the threat of social isolation constant. I always knew that our schools and indeed our curriculum urgently needed to take proactive action to challenge rampant homophobia. A few visits to public schools in decades since, with the frequent casual use of "gay" and "fag" and "dyke" overheard in hallways, reinforced this need. We know bullying remains a crisis in our schools. Not to mention the various new issues kids are now facing.
Finally in 2015, the curriculum was updated and, among other advancements, mentions of LGBTQ people were added. It was long overdue.
This is why I'm so angry about what Doug Ford and the Ontario PCs have done. They have bowed to bigotry and ignorance. By reverting to the old curriculum which erases LGBTQ people from any official mention, then threatening teachers with a snitch website, the message was clear. It matters not that months later Crown prosecutors are backtracking, claiming teachers still have the right to use the 2015 curriculum as a resource.
Shame on Doug Ford and the conservatives who have empowered him in this awful decision. If this year's "consultation" simply returns most or all of the 2015 curriculum to our province's classrooms, then this process has been a sham. But I have no trust in Ford or his colleagues to do the right thing.
Hence, why the court fight is crucial. I hope the good side prevails.
I'm proud of the parents, activists and groups who are leading this legal charge to return the modernized curriculum to our classrooms.
This great article by Martin Regg Cohn sums up the situation nicely, putting it in full context.
It's not enough for these conservative folks fighting the modern curriculum that they have always had the ability to remove their kids from sex education public school lessons (even though in my mind their kids most certainly need to learn them considering the backwards homes they are growing up in.) I can only think of the lasting damage caused to any unfortunate, lonely LGBTQ kids living in those homes by their parents' actions.
Yes it is important to protect kids from abuse, both in their homes and their schools. I firmly support the ability of greater society to create inclusive and healthy public school environments for all of us.
When I was a kid growing up, I was luckily in a family not too conservative. My family was fairly typical for the time period of the 1980s and 1990s. Since I came out of the closet to them all, our family situation has been pretty great, glad to say.
But high school was an awful experience, trying to survive amid the hotbed of homophobia that was mainstream back then. Social isolation was the rule of the day. Suicide was contemplated on occasion, but somehow I made it through without ever trying. Perhaps the faint hope of some kind of future as a gay adult kept me alive. Yet there was, of course, barely any mention of LGBT lives in my classrooms. Homosexuality came up on occasion. Most students were hostile to gay folk. Teachers, on the other hand, never indoctrinated or perpetuated ignorance or discrimination, even in my Catholic school environment.
Yet overall, the environment was hostile with the threat of social isolation constant. I always knew that our schools and indeed our curriculum urgently needed to take proactive action to challenge rampant homophobia. A few visits to public schools in decades since, with the frequent casual use of "gay" and "fag" and "dyke" overheard in hallways, reinforced this need. We know bullying remains a crisis in our schools. Not to mention the various new issues kids are now facing.
Finally in 2015, the curriculum was updated and, among other advancements, mentions of LGBTQ people were added. It was long overdue.
This is why I'm so angry about what Doug Ford and the Ontario PCs have done. They have bowed to bigotry and ignorance. By reverting to the old curriculum which erases LGBTQ people from any official mention, then threatening teachers with a snitch website, the message was clear. It matters not that months later Crown prosecutors are backtracking, claiming teachers still have the right to use the 2015 curriculum as a resource.
Shame on Doug Ford and the conservatives who have empowered him in this awful decision. If this year's "consultation" simply returns most or all of the 2015 curriculum to our province's classrooms, then this process has been a sham. But I have no trust in Ford or his colleagues to do the right thing.
Hence, why the court fight is crucial. I hope the good side prevails.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)